If you browse a lot of different websites, you have definitely come across the ones that have a banner or a pop-up and require your permission to store cookies. It’s called a cookie consent banner; they’ve been around for a while. Why? Because of regulations like GDPR and CCPA. To protect user privacy and allow visitors control over their own data, many international laws have made it mandatory for websites to ask for explicit permissions before they can store user data.
CookieYes and CookieScript are two popular Consent Management Platforms (CMP) that help with compliance with international regulations and automate the process of managing cookie consent. They both have the basics covered, but at the same time, they are for two very different user bases with different compliance needs. If you’re considering investing in a CMP and are stuck between these two options, we’re going to try to make that decision easy for you.
Comparison Overview
Before we get to the details, let’s look at a quick side-by-side comparison of CookieYes and CookieScript to see how they stack up against each other.
Criteria | CookieYes | CookieScript |
Best For | Small to medium-sized businesses, non-technical users | Medium-sized businesses, agencies, and enterprises |
Stand-out Features | Simple setup, user-friendly interface, budget-friendly | Dynamic third-party cookie blocking and detailed analytics |
Usability | Highly intuitive, minimal learning curve | Requires an involved setup, a learning curve |
Compliance | GDPR, CCPA, ePrivacy, LGPD, CNIL | GDPR, CCPA, LGPD, CNIL, KVKK, PIPEDA |
Support | Email, Help guides, Knowledge base | Ticket, AI Live Chat, Help centre |
Starts At | $10/month | €8/month |
CookieYes
CookieYes is a simple and affordable consent management tool that takes a lot of the hassle out of cookie compliance.
Pros and Cons of CookieYes
Pros
- Easy and non-technical
- Compliant with multiple regional privacy laws, including GDPR and CCPA
- Customisable cookie banners to match your website’s style
- Generates privacy and cookie policies for your site
- Free plan is perfect for small blogs or low-traffic websites
Cons
- Free plan has limited features
- Advanced integrations are limited compared to others
Why Should You Choose CookieYes?
CookieYes is the simplest solution for anyone looking to comply with cookies. It’s built with automation in mind and has features like a cookie scanner, consent logger, privacy policy generator and script blocker. These features save time and make you compliant with global standards with minimal effort. One of the best features of CookieYes is geo-targeting, which automatically localises cookie banners and policies based on user region. Plus, it integrates seamlessly with major CMS platforms like WordPress, Squarespace, and Shopify.
If you’re a small to medium-sized business (SMB) or an individual who manages a blog, CookieYes checks all the boxes. It’s cheap, compliant with significant privacy laws and has a free plan that’s good enough to get you started. If you want simplicity and cost-effectiveness, CookieYes is the winner. Read full CookieYes review here.
CookieScript
CookieScript is an open-source, scalable solution to consent management and cookie compliance.
Pros and Cons of CookieScript
Pros
- Highly customisable cookie banners with geo-targeting
- Supports up to 34 languages
- Comprehensive privacy policy generator
- Affordable premium plans
- Advanced cookie control and script manager
Cons
- Free plan is too limited
- No short-term subscription options
- No single-domain option
Why Should You Choose CookieScript?
What sets CookieScript apart is the dynamic blocking of first and third-party cookies, so you can have full control of what gets loaded on your site. It also supports geo-targeting, multi-language banners, and detailed analytics, so it’s perfect for sites with diverse and international audiences. Customisation is another key feature of CookieScript; you can brand your cookie banners to match your website.
Now, the real reason for choosing CookieScript is that it’s cheap. How cheap? Well, it starts at €8/month, the same as most other CMPs, except it offers consent management for two domains instead of one. This is the reason it’s not exactly suitable for small businesses that don’t need two domains and would rather have more features. But for agencies that deal with multiple domains, the more websites you manage, the cheaper it gets. So you get the top Plus tier for €216/month for 200 websites. If you do the math, that brings the price down to over €1 a month. This is what makes CookieScript a great choice for agencies on a budget.
Verdict
So, if you want a cookie compliance solution that’s super easy and affordable. CookieYes makes it super easy for small business owners and bloggers. You don’t need to hire someone to deal with cookie compliance and consent management. Based on your traffic, you could even get away with the free plan if you serve a niche audience.
However, CookieScript offers a similar experience with high customisability. Now, you need a little bit of technical know-how to set it up, and it does not lean on automation as much as CookieYes does. But it makes up for all that with its scalability and price. It’s very cheap to begin with, and it keeps getting cheaper as you add more domains.
If you run a blog or a website for your small audience, you can’t go wrong with CookieYes. But suppose you’re an agency working for multiple clients with complex compliance needs or someone handling a multi-domain operation for a large enterprise-level business. In that case, CookieScript is the way to go.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a consent management platform?
A Consent Management Platform (CMP) is a tool that helps websites and apps comply with data privacy laws like GDPR, CCPA, and more. It manages user consent for cookies and data collection by providing transparent information about how data will be used and allowing users to accept or reject cookies. Many CMPs also automate cookie scanning, consent logging, and privacy policy generation.
Which cookie banner is best?
CookieScript offers one of the best cookie banners due to its high level of customisation. It allows you to adjust everything from colours and layouts to button styles, making it easy to align the banner with your website’s branding.
Which CMP is easiest to set up?
CookieYes is the easiest Consent Management Platform to set up. Its user-friendly interface and straightforward process require no technical expertise. Simply integrate it with your website or CMS like WordPress or Shopify, and CookieYes handles the rest.